The same 30 everyday grocery items cost $161.23 at the cheapest Toronto chain and $198.75 at the most expensive, a gap of $37.52 for the same cart.
We priced a 30-item cart at 104 stores across eight Toronto grocery chains in November 2026. Walmart came out cheapest, Sobeys the most expensive. But no chain was cheapest on everything, and that is where the real savings are. Buying each item at the chain where it was cheapest would have cost $133.76, which is $27.47 (17%) less than shopping the cheapest chain for the whole list.
How we built the cart
We picked 30 items a typical household buys every week, all with a specific brand and size so each chain is priced on the same thing wherever possible. Prices are the shelf prices listed online at 104 Toronto-area stores (Toronto, North York, Scarborough and Etobicoke), including whatever was on sale that week. For each chain we use the median store.
The cart:
Pantry and cupboard: Heinz ketchup 1 L, Campbell's chicken noodle soup 284 mL, Clover Leaf light tuna 170 g, Christie crackers 450 g, Kraft smooth peanut butter 1 kg, Kraft salad dressing 425 mL, Bonne Maman jam 250 mL, Gallo olive oil 1 L, Old El Paso large tortillas, Quick oats 1 kg
Fridge and deli: Philadelphia cream cheese 250 g, Activia yogurt 650 g, Gay Lea sour cream 500 mL, Fontaine Sante hummus, Maple Leaf Top Dogs 375 g, Maple Leaf Natural Selections deli ham, Schneiders bacon 375 g, Cheddar cheese block 400 g
Dairy basics: 2% milk 4 L, large eggs (dozen), salted butter 454 g
Bakery and breakfast: Dempster's bagels 450 g, white bread 675 g, Tropicana orange juice 1.36 L
Frozen: McCain Superfries 650 g, Dr. Oetker Ristorante pizza
Produce and meat: bananas, Gala apples, boneless skinless chicken breasts, lean ground beef
The chains: Walmart (10 stores priced), No Frills (34), Food Basics (5), FreshCo (12), Real Canadian Superstore (3), Loblaws (16), Metro (18) and Sobeys (6).
The results: Walmart cheapest, Sobeys priciest
The median-store cart total at each chain:
Walmart: $161.23
No Frills: $165.10
Food Basics: $165.66
FreshCo: $168.60
Real Canadian Superstore: $187.70
Loblaws: $190.77
Metro: $196.61
Sobeys: $198.75
The chains split into two groups. Walmart, No Frills, Food Basics and FreshCo sit within $7.37 of each other. Superstore, Loblaws, Metro and Sobeys all land $26 to $37 above Walmart.
The store you pick within a chain matters too. Across the 34 No Frills stores we priced, cart totals ranged from $155.22 to $170.11. Across 18 Metro stores, from $190.50 to $211.60.
Two caveats. Meat is sold in different pack sizes at different chains, and it moves the totals: Superstore's chicken pack (1.41 kg), for example, is the largest we priced. Leaving the chicken and beef out, the cheapest chain is still Walmart ($126.65) and the priciest still Sobeys ($159.64), a gap of $32.99. Second, a few chains price bananas and Walmart prices apples by weight, so those prices are converted to a typical bunch or bag. Superstore (3 stores) and Food Basics (5) are smaller samples than the others.
No chain was cheapest on everything
Walmart had the lowest price on 12 of the 30 items, more than any other chain. But the others were not shut out. Counting ties, here is how many items each chain had the lowest price on:
Walmart: 12
No Frills: 9
Food Basics: 7
Real Canadian Superstore: 5
FreshCo: 4
Loblaws: 3
Metro: 2
Sobeys: 2
Even the two priciest chains, Metro and Sobeys, were cheapest on a couple of items. Which chain wins depends on what is in your cart.
The surprises, and the split-the-cart savings
Pricier chains win some items outright:
Loblaws had Bonne Maman jam (250 mL) at $6.00. Every other chain charged $6.78 to $8.99.
Sobeys had Maple Leaf Top Dogs (375 g) at $3.99, while other chains charged $4.50 to $8.00.
Real Canadian Superstore had McCain Superfries (650 g) at $2.77, against $2.98 to $5.99 elsewhere.
Sales explain a lot of this. 31% of the 3,120 prices we collected were on sale, at an average of 20% off. Food Basics (44% of prices on sale) and No Frills (39%) ran the most promotions in our cart, and Walmart and FreshCo (23% each) the fewest. A chain that is expensive on a normal week can still have the best price on one item this week.
That is why splitting the list works. Buying the whole cart at Walmart, the cheapest single chain, cost $161.23. Buying each of the 30 items at the chain where it was cheapest cost $133.76. That is $27.47 less, or 17%.
What this means for your grocery bill
There is no single best grocery store in Toronto. There is a best store for each item, this week. A few ways to use that:
Check the whole list before you shop. A $37 gap on 30 items means roughly $1.25 per item for choosing the wrong chain.
Do not assume a big name is expensive or cheap. Every chain in our cart was cheapest on at least two items.
Check your own store. Totals varied by up to $21 between stores of the same chain.
Watch the sales. Roughly one price in three was a promotion, and they change every week.
That is what SAVR is built for. Add your grocery list and SAVR prices it across the stores near you, so you can see where each item is cheapest before you leave home. SAVR is free on iPhone and Android: download it at savr.app on the App Store or Google Play.
Source: SAVR, November 11, 2026