Thanksgiving's cheapest dinner was at the "expensive" grocery store

SAVR Team ·

Compare grocery prices across 26 Canadian stores

Try SAVR Free

Ask anyone in Toronto where to save money on groceries and you'll hear the same names: No Frills, Food Basics, FreshCo. The discount chains. Loblaws and Metro are where you go when you're not counting.

This Thanksgiving, that was backwards.

At SAVR, we build a grocery app that does one thing most shoppers never have time for. You make your list, pick the stores near you, and SAVR prices the whole list at each one, so you can see which store is actually cheapest for what you're buying. We wanted to see what that looked like for a holiday dinner.

How we checked

We priced one Thanksgiving list at one store per chain in downtown Toronto: Food Basics, FreshCo, Loblaws, Metro and No Frills. The list was a 7 kg frozen turkey plus 11 staples for about eight people, from potatoes and Brussels sprouts to butter, cranberries and bread.

We ran the same check three times: the week before Thanksgiving (Oct 7), Thanksgiving week (Oct 12) and the week after (Oct 18). Each check returned about 1,250 prices.

The week before Thanksgiving, the "premium" stores were cheapest

The cheapest full dinner was at Loblaws, at $74.48. Metro was second at $78.41. FreshCo came in at $82.14. The two stores with discount in their DNA were the most expensive.

  • Loblaws: $74.48. Turkey at $4.39 a kilogram ($30.73 for 7 kg) plus $43.75 in sides.

  • Metro: $78.41. Turkey at $4.39 a kilogram ($30.73 for 7 kg) plus $47.68 in sides.

  • FreshCo: $82.14. Turkey at $5.49 a kilogram ($38.43 for 7 kg) plus $43.71 in sides.

  • No Frills: $93.31. Turkey at $7.03 a kilogram ($49.21 for 7 kg) plus $44.10 in sides.

  • Food Basics: $102.66. Turkey at $8.80 a kilogram ($61.60 for 7 kg) plus $41.06 in sides.

That's a $28 gap, or 27%, between the "premium" grocer and the discount one. On a single dinner.

Here's where it gets stranger. Loblaws and No Frills belong to the same parent company, and so do Metro and Food Basics. In both pairs, the premium banner undercut its own discount sister. Loblaws beat No Frills by $18.83. Metro beat Food Basics by $24.25. I can't tell you whether anyone planned it that way. I can tell you a shopper who went to the discount store to save money paid more.

The turkey made the difference

Loblaws and Metro both sold frozen turkey at $4.39 a kilogram, a classic loss leader. That's an item sold cheap to get you in the door. No Frills charged $7.03 and Food Basics $8.80. On a 7 kg bird, that's a difference of up to $31.

Strip out the turkey and the old order mostly returns. Food Basics had the cheapest side dishes of the five, at $41.06. Metro had the most expensive, at $47.68. Metro and Loblaws had the same turkey price, and Loblaws won the dinner by $3.93 on sides alone.

Then the deal ended

Metro kept its $4.39 turkey through Thanksgiving week. Loblaws had already moved to $7.69. By the week after Thanksgiving, Metro's turkey was $9.90 a kilogram, 2.3 times its Thanksgiving week price, and Loblaws' was $8.80.

The cheapest turkey at any of the five stores that week was FreshCo's $5.49, still 25% above the pre-holiday deal. Price the same dinner then and the order changes completely: Metro, the second cheapest dinner a week earlier, was now the most expensive of the five.

Metro also raised more prices than any other chain. Of the products we could follow between Oct 7 and Oct 18, Metro raised the price of 25% and cut 4%. No Frills cut the most, at 13%.

The side dishes got pricier too

The same 11 side dishes cost more the week after Thanksgiving than the week before at four of the five stores: 12% more at both Loblaws and Metro, 17% more at Food Basics and 6% more at FreshCo. No Frills was the only store where they got cheaper, down 5%.

Fresh produce drove it. Added up across all five stores, the increase was $18.73, and produce made up 88% of it. Brussels sprouts alone added $6.04, carrots $3.41 and sweet potatoes $3.32. Milk, bread, broth and potatoes barely moved.

Some of the best deals were on big bags

Some of the best prices before Thanksgiving were on big bags of staples, and most had climbed by Thanksgiving week. A 10 lb bag of white potatoes at No Frills went from $1.99 to $3.99 to $5.99. A 10 lb bag of yellow onions at FreshCo went from $2.99 to $7.99. A 3 lb bag of carrots at Loblaws doubled, from $1.50 to $3.00.

Shopping around paid most before the holiday

We also asked what happens if you split the side dishes across stores and buy each item wherever it is cheapest (turkey not included). The week before Thanksgiving, that cost $34.04 against $41.06 at the cheapest single store, a saving of 17%. In Thanksgiving week the saving was 16%. The week after, it fell to 4%, or $1.86.

Each chain put different items on sale for the holiday, which is why the savings were spread across stores.

What this does and doesn't show

Our check has limits. It covers one store per chain, in one part of one city, using the prices each store lists online. Other locations price differently, and one holiday isn't a trend. A fourth check on Oct 15 is left out because Food Basics and Metro came back incomplete.

But it shows how little a store's reputation tells you about this week's bill. "Discount" is a brand, not a price.

Before the Christmas flyers

Christmas flyers are coming, and they'll lead with a deal too. Before you shop, price the whole list, not the headline item, at more than one store. The cheapest place to buy your dinner might be the one you'd never think to check.

SAVR does that for you. Build your list, pick your stores and see where the whole cart costs the least. It's free on iPhone and Android: App Store link | Google Play link

Start saving on groceries today

Join thousands of Canadians comparing prices across 26 stores.

Try SAVR Free