Does Halloween candy go on sale after Halloween?

SAVR Team ·

Compare grocery prices across 26 Canadian stores

Try SAVR Free

Most people know the move. Skip the candy aisle in October, wait for November 1, and stock up at half price.

This year, there wasn't much left to stock up on. Within days of Halloween, most of the Halloween candy was gone.

That sounds like bad news for bargain hunters. We think it's a sign the stores got Halloween right.

How we checked

We built two Halloween lists with SAVR and priced each one at five stores. One was in downtown Toronto, at Food Basics, FreshCo, Loblaws, Metro and No Frills. The other was in Vaughan, at Fortinos, No Frills, FreshCo, Food Basics and Walmart.

We checked the week before Halloween (Oct 24), Halloween week (Oct 29 and Nov 2), the week after (Nov 5) and two weeks after (Nov 12). That came to 11,231 prices across 10 searches, compared product by product at the same store.

Stores ordered about the right amount

In Vaughan, our list turned up 60 Halloween-branded candy and snack items the week before Halloween. On Monday, Nov 2, it turned up 12. Downtown, 29 items on Oct 29 became 8 by Nov 2, and 4 by Nov 12.

That's 70 to 80% of the Halloween stock gone within days. Halloween is one of the most predictable shopping weeks of the year, and it looks like stores planned for it. They stocked enough for the rush and not much more, so there was little left over to clear out.

That's good planning. Every leftover bag of seasonal candy has to be marked down, moved to another aisle or sent back, and none of that is free.

Some prices still moved

A handful of Halloween items did get marked down after the holiday, some by half or more. A few Halloween sales also ended, and those prices went back up.

Prices also shifted partway through the flyer week. That surprised us enough that it's getting its own post.

Regular candy didn't move

Candy without Halloween branding barely changed. Chocolate bars, KitKats, gummies, marshmallows and caramels all stayed within 5% of their Oct 24 price at every store for all four weeks. Every big move we found was on a Halloween-branded pack.

Downtown or Vaughan, same price

No Frills, FreshCo and Food Basics charged the same price for the same product downtown and in Vaughan, every week we checked. Across hundreds of matching products, the only exceptions were 3 harvest decorations at No Frills on Oct 24. Each of those chains priced the whole region as one.

Before the Christmas flyers

At Thanksgiving, the best deal came the week before the holiday. Metro's frozen turkey went from $4.39 a kilogram the week before to $9.90 the week after (read the Thanksgiving check). Halloween followed the same pattern, with the deals early and little left to clear afterwards.

Christmas flyers are coming. Price your whole list the week before, at more than one store, while the deals are still running.

We built SAVR so you don't have to do that by hand. Make your list, pick the stores near you, and SAVR prices the whole list at each one, so you can see which store is actually cheapest for what you're buying.

It's free on iPhone, Android and the web: App Store link | Google Play link | Web link

Start saving on groceries today

Join thousands of Canadians comparing prices across 26 stores.

Try SAVR Free